> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://wusul.io/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Does A Colder Winter Raise More Money?
- URL: https://wusul.io/insights/does-a-colder-winter-raise-more-money/
- Published: 2026-11-18T04:20:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-19T15:45:03.000Z
- Author: Wusul Research Team
- Tags: Strategy

Listen18 min · British voice

Winter appeals assume that the colder it gets, the more people give. This article, the sixth in Wusul's winter series, tests that assumption against the research and against real winters, and finds that what moves money is less the cold than whether anyone sees it.

In late February 2018, the "Beast from the East" brought Britain its harshest cold in years. In Suffolk, a winter appeal that helps older people heat their homes found itself overwhelmed. Its organisers said that, with six weeks of the season still to go, they had[ already exceeded the entire previous year's requests for help, without any significant increase in donations](https://www.eadt.co.uk/news/final-push-for-suffolk-surviving-winter-appeal-as-beast-from-2432524?ref=wusul.io).

Three years later, a winter storm left millions of Texans without power. Within less than a week,[ more than $235,000 poured in on GoFundMe](https://trf-legacy-prod.dotcms.cloud/item/20210217220921-zdqv3?ref=wusul.io) for a single mutual-aid group housing homeless people in Austin, from donors across the United States and abroad.

Both were extreme cold events. In one, need surged and giving stood still. In the other, giving surged within days. The difference was not simply the temperature. The Texas storm was a national news story, with images of people freezing in their homes and a simple way to help. Suffolk's crisis was real, local and largely unseen.

Winter fundraising rests on an assumption: the colder the winter, the greater the need, and the more people give. The first part is usually true. The second is not guaranteed. This article examines what research says about cold and giving, what Wusul's own evidence shows about attention, and why, for [Muslim charities](https://wusul.io/islamic-charity-index/), the weather may not even be the most important variable in a winter's results.

## Cold is not the same as need

A meteorologist measures winter in degrees, snowfall, wind and days below freezing. A humanitarian agency must measure something else. Minus five degrees is an inconvenience for a family in an insulated flat with working heating. For a displaced family in a tent, with no fuel and wet bedding, it is a danger to life.

What creates a humanitarian winter is cold combined with vulnerability: how many people are exposed, for how long, in what kind of shelter, with what access to fuel, clothing and health care, and whether help can reach them before the coldest weeks. A moderate winter in Gaza, where much of the population has lived in tents and damaged buildings since 2023, can do more harm than a severe one in a city with intact homes and power.

This matters for the question in the title. If need is cold multiplied by vulnerability, then a colder winter raise need most where vulnerability is highest. But those are often the places donors see least. The question is not only whether cold raises need, but whether the need it raises ever reaches the people who might pay to meet it.

![An infographic titled Cold Is Not the Same as Need explaining that need is calculated by multiplying cold by vulnerability](https://wusul.io/content/images/2026/11/Does-a-Colder-Winter-Raise-More-Money---2-Cold-Is-Not-Need.png)

## What research says about cold and the donor

There are two different questions hidden in the title. One is whether people give more when *they* feel cold. The other is whether a cold winter *where aid is needed* raises more money. The research on the first is stronger than many fundraisers realise.

In three experiments, Rai, Lin and Yang found that[ cold, rather than warm, temperature cues increased intentions to donate](https://emeraldinsight.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/JCM-07-2015-1505/full/html?ref=wusul.io), because feeling cold activates a need for social connection. The effect held when the actual room temperature was changed and when real donations were measured. A later set of four studies, including a field study in a coffee shop, reached a similar conclusion: feeling cold, or seeing cold imagery,[ raises the desire for social connection and empathy, and with it the likelihood of giving](https://doaj.org/article/e19e521d249a4bd498cf2472c80c331b?ref=wusul.io).

So, a donor in a cold city, looking at an image of snow on tents, may be slightly more inclined to give. But there is a counterweight. Winter in donor countries is also the season of Christmas, year-end bills, high heating costs and an avalanche of competing appeals. Experimental work by Müller and Rau, published in *PLOS ONE* in 2019, found lower average donations in the Christmas season than in summer, pointing to stress and consumption as part of the explanation.

None of this answers the second question. A psychological nudge on individual donors is not the same as a campaign's revenue rising with the severity of winter in Syria or Gaza. For that, the more important variable turns out to be not temperature, but attention.

## Attention: the variable that moves money

The evidence that news coverage drives disaster giving is long-standing and consistent.

After the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami, Brown and Minty found that an additional minute of nightly news, or an extra story in a major newspaper,[ raised online donations by 17-21%](https://econpapers.repec.org/RePEc:wly:soecon:v:75:y:2008:i:1:p:9-25?ref=wusul.io). When they used instrumental variables to separate cause from correlation, the effect of a minute of television fell to about 2.5%, still significant. The drop is itself a lesson: simple correlations between coverage and giving overstate the effect.

Attention can also be crowded out. Studying some 5,000 natural disasters between 1968 and 2002, Eisensee and Strömberg concluded that US government relief decisions were[ driven by news coverage, and that other newsworthy events crowded that coverage out](https://hats.arizona.edu/node/301?ref=wusul.io). A disaster that coincides with a bigger story receives less help. Research on wartime giving in Ukraine, covering nearly 2.9 million donations, found the same pattern from the donor side:[ civilian fatalities and frontline media reports each produced immediate increases](https://cepr.org/voxeu/columns/charitable-giving-wartime-evidence-ukraines-war-fundraising?ref=wusul.io) in giving.

Wusul has measured this directly for Muslim charities. In[ an analysis of 22 months of a partner charity's data](https://wusul.io/insights/gaza-news-coverage-donations/), Wusul found that new donors to Gaza appeals tracked news attention closely: a 10% fall in attention was associated with roughly 4% to 8% fewer new Gaza donors, in the same week, after controlling for the [Islamic calendar](https://wusul.io/insights/why-understanding-the-muslim-calendar-is-important/). Existing donors were far less sensitive.

![An infographic titled Attention Is the Variable That Moves Money showing how news coverage impacts disaster giving for charities](https://wusul.io/content/images/2026/11/Does-a-Colder-Winter-Raise-More-Money---3-Attention-Moves-Money.png)

Two refinements matter for winter. A 2013 study by Waters of US television coverage of three major disasters, published in the *Journal of Public Relations Research*, found that generic disaster coverage did little for individual charities, but same-day donations rose when reports named an organisation or featured its spokespeople. Crisis visibility and organisational visibility are different things. And what moves first-time donors most is not the cold, but the moment the cold becomes a story.

## The invisible winter

If attention drives giving, the corollary is uncomfortable: much need goes unfunded simply because it is not seen. A 2023 study in *Oxford Economic Papers* of donations to natural disasters on an online giving platform found that most money went to a small number of severe, heavily covered disasters, and that charities on the platform did not fundraise at all for 96% of disasters in the sample, even though those disasters accounted for 80% of deaths.

Winter is especially prone to this. A prolonged cold season in a displacement camp rarely produces a single dramatic moment. Families endure weeks of damp, cold nights, burning plastic for warmth, children falling ill, without a storm that makes the evening news. The Suffolk appeal in 2018 is a small example from Britain: the cold was severe and the need was record-breaking, but it was a local story, and donations did not follow.

This is what we might call the invisible winter: hardship that is real, predictable and widespread, but never quite becomes an event. It has an ethical edge for charities. If funding follows images, the families in the most persistent danger may be the least supported, and the temptation will be to wait for, or manufacture, the dramatic moment.

## Four winters

Put severity of need on one axis and public attention on the other, and the evidence so far sorts into four kinds of winter.

![A two by two matrix titled Four Winters plots public attention against severity of need to categorize different fundraising scenarios](https://wusul.io/content/images/2026/11/Does-a-Colder-Winter-Raise-More-Money---4-Four-Winters.png)

The Gulf cases from the[ previous article in this series](https://wusul.io/insights/) belong in the top right. Qatar's Rescue Arsal campaign was launched after Storm Norma hit Syrian refugees in Lebanon in January 2019; Haq Al-Sham followed the largest displacement wave of the Syrian war, in the depth of winter 2020, and raised more than QAR 149 million during a live broadcast. In both, severe cold and intense attention coincided, and giving was enormous.

The bottom right is where the hardest ethical questions sit. The need is greatest, and the response weakest, because nothing makes it news. The bottom left, the routine annual appeal, is where most winter fundraising actually happens, and where, as this series has found in the US, Britain and the Gulf, the amount raised is least often published. A useful test of any fundraising strategy is how it performs in the bottom half of this chart.

## Three clocks, and a fourth

Even with good data, comparing winter weather with winter donations is harder than it looks, because three different clocks are running.

- **The weather clock:** when temperatures fall, storms arrive and the coldest weeks hit.
- **The humanitarian clock:** when families need help, when supplies must be bought and pre-positioned, and when aid is delivered, often months before the cold.
- **The fundraising clock:** when appeals launch, advertising peaks, and donations arrive, typically in November and December, around GivingTuesday and the end of the tax year.

These rarely line up. A campaign may hit its target in December, while the worst cold comes in February. A simple monthly comparison would then suggest that giving falls as it gets colder, when it simply reflects the fundraising calendar.

For Muslim charities there is a fourth clock, and for the rest of this decade it may matter more than the weather: **the** [**Hijri calendar**](https://wusul.io/calendar/). Ramadan moves about eleven days earlier each year. It began on 1 March in 2025 and around 18 February in 2026 and is expected in early February in 2027 and in January from 2028; in 2030 it will begin twice in one Gregorian year. Ramadan is when much Zakat is paid and when Muslim giving peaks.

![An infographic titled Three Clocks, and a Fourth explaining why winter weather and winter donations do not align for charities](https://wusul.io/content/images/2026/11/Does-a-Colder-Winter-Raise-More-Money---5-Four-Clocks.png)

That means a rise in "winter" donations between 2024 and 2030 may have little to do with the cold. It may be Ramadan, falling for the first time in a generation in the coldest weeks of the northern winter. Any analysis of winter giving to Muslim charities that ignores the Hijri calendar will mistake a religious season for a weather effect. Wusul's Gaza study controlled for Ramadan and Dhul Hijjah for exactly this reason.

## Coats before cash

There is one more reason a cold snap may not show up in donation figures: people often respond to cold with things, not money.

During cold snaps in Britain, homeless charities have reported[ a surge in public donations of food, clothes and sleeping bags](https://www.inkl.com/news/charities-respond-to-record-number-of-alerts-over-rough-sleeping?ref=wusul.io), and Street Link, the service that lets the public alert outreach teams to people sleeping rough, recorded[ its highest number of alerts since launch](https://www.inkl.com/news/record-number-of-homeless-people-alerted-to-authorities-amid-freezing-temperatures?ref=wusul.io) during the 2018 "Beast from the East", as more than 13,600 members of the public signed up to help. In Michigan, during a 2021 freeze, local homeless organisations reported[ more cash gifts and offers of blankets, socks, gloves and coats](https://www.pressreader.com/usa/the-oakland-press/20210216/281479279120356?ref=wusul.io).

This matters for measurement. As the[ Britain article in this series](https://wusul.io/insights/) found, donated clothing rarely appears in a charity's income at its real value, and some is sold or recycled. A study that counts only money will miss much of the public's response to cold, especially for domestic appeals, where giving a coat is easy and immediate. The in-kind response may be precisely where the cold effect is strongest.

## What this means for fundraisers

**Plan around vulnerability, not forecasts.** Winter aid has to be bought and moved before the cold. A campaign that waits for a cold snap to make its case raises money after the moment it was most needed. Make the case early, based on who is exposed, and explain why help must arrive before the worst weeks.

**Separate attention from performance.** When donations rise after a storm makes the news, record it as an attention effect, not as proof that the campaign worked better. Track news coverage alongside revenue, so that next year's forecast does not assume the same storm.

**Be visible as an organisation, not only the crisis.** The research suggests coverage helps a charity most when the charity itself is named or heard. In a cold spell, having a spokesperson and a clear, specific way to help matters more than another image of snow.

**Read results through the Hijri calendar.** Until about 2030, compare winter campaigns year on year only after allowing for Ramadan's position. Otherwise, a calendar effect will look like a fundraising success or failure.

**Count the coats.** Record in-kind gifts alongside cash, or the public's response to cold will be underestimated.

### The ethics of weather appeals

If cold and dramatic images raise more money, charities face a temptation: to wait for the storm, to show the most harrowing pictures, or to describe a cold spell as unprecedented. A family in a damaged building without heating is in danger whether or not it snows. Campaigns should not use old footage as current, claim record cold without evidence, or let one storm stand for a whole winter. The responsibility of humanitarian communication is not merely to make suffering visible. It is to represent it accurately.

## Conclusion: the coldest winter is not the best funded

Does a colder winter raise more money? The evidence says: not by itself. Feeling cold may nudge individual donors towards generosity. But what turns a hard winter into a fundraising response is attention: a storm that becomes news, an organisation that is named, a clear way to help. Suffolk in 2018 shows severe cold with flat donations; Texas in 2021 and Qatar's Haq Al-Sham in 2020 show severe cold with an extraordinary response. The temperature alone did not decide the difference.

For Muslim charities, two further cautions apply. Until about 2030, Ramadan falls in winter, so winter results will reflect the religious calendar as much as the weather. And much of the public's response to cold arrives as coats and blankets, which money-only figures miss.

The question can be answered properly, with campaign data, local temperatures, measures of attention and the Hijri calendar, using a method Wusul has already applied to Gaza. Until it is, charities should not assume that need and giving rise together. They can. They can also move in opposite directions.

![A quote card about humanitarian fundraising featuring a line graph showing fluctuating attention versus a steady line of sustained support](https://wusul.io/content/images/2026/11/Does-a-Colder-Winter-Raise-More-Money---6C.png)

## Frequently asked questions

### Do people donate more when it is cold?

Experiments suggest feeling cold can make individuals slightly more willing to give, because it raises the desire for social connection. That is different from showing that colder winters raise more money for humanitarian appeals.

### Does a severe winter increase donations to winter appeals?

Not reliably. Severe cold raises need, but donations rise most when the cold becomes visible through news coverage and a clear way to help. In Suffolk in 2018, requests for help surged while donations barely changed.

### How much does media coverage affect giving?

After the 2004 tsunami, an extra minute of nightly news was linked to 17-21% more online donations, falling to about 2.5% in a stricter causal analysis. Wusul's Gaza analysis found new donors fell by roughly 4-8% for every 10% fall in news attention.

### Why does Ramadan matter for winter fundraising?

Ramadan moves about eleven days earlier each year and falls in winter until around 2030\. Because much Zakat and Muslim giving happens in Ramadan, winter results for Muslim charities in these years will partly reflect the Islamic calendar, not the weather.

### Should charities use cold-weather images in appeals?

They can, if accurate. Images should be current, claims about record cold should be backed by evidence, and one storm should not stand for a whole season.

### Has anyone measured the effect of winter severity on Muslim charity donations?

Not publicly, as far as Wusul is aware. It would require campaign-level donation data combined with local temperatures, measures of media attention and the Hijri calendar.

**Wusul Insight:** Cold raises need; attention raises money. For Muslim charities, the Hijri calendar adds a third force, with Ramadan in winter until about 2030\. Charities that plan around vulnerability rather than weather, track attention separately from performance, and count in-kind gifts will read their winter results more accurately, and fund the winters nobody sees.

*Research note: this article reviews published research and real cases; it does not present an original statistical estimate of the effect of winter severity on donations. The cases illustrate patterns and are not a representative sample. Findings from experiments on individual donors are not treated as evidence about campaign revenue. The proposed study design builds on Wusul's published Gaza analysis.*

---

### Related reading

- [December Is Not Britain's Tax Deadline: Why Muslim Charities Still Run Year-End Appeals](https://wusul.io/insights/december-is-not-britains-tax-deadline-why-muslim-charities-still-run-year-end-appeals/)
- [The Last Gift of the Year: Why The Year-End Matters To Muslim Charities](https://wusul.io/insights/the-last-gift-of-the-year-why-the-year-end-matters-to-muslim-charities/)
- [Is "Halal" As A Marketing Label Losing Power With Young Muslims?](https://wusul.io/insights/is-halal-as-a-marketing-label-losing-power-with-young-muslims/)